Real-time TCG market data, portfolio tracking & price alerts View Plans
Markets › MTG › Chthonian Nightmare
Chthonian Nightmare
MTG

Chthonian Nightmare Price

Modern Horizons 3 · #83 · Rare · Foil - Japanese
$4.50 ▲ +354.6% 7d +354.6% 30d
7D HIGH
—
7D LOW
—
7D AVG
—
30D AVG
PRICE HISTORY: NM

MARKET NOTE: CHTHONIAN NIGHTMARE

Updated 2026-05-06

Chthonian Nightmare is locked in a dead flat hold at $1.99 NM across all measured timeframes, with zero movement over 7 days, 30 days, and a peak-to-current spread of +0.0%. The foil Japanese printing shows no price discovery since capture began 26 days ago, sitting at identical levels to both its recorded peak and trough. This suggests minimal liquidity friction either direction, which typically means weak demand or constrained supply preventing any real contest over fair value. Zero volatility in a Modern Horizons 3 rare usually signals either low spec interest or a card that failed to establish a chase or money mythic narrative. The data reads as investor indifference rather than a healthy consolidation. Watch for sudden volume or repricing pressure if the card gains EDH traction or if Japanese foil premium starts moving relative to other printings; absent that catalyst, this spec looks cooked.

⚡ Get the Weekly Edge — the movers report for cards like this, free every Monday

Should I Grade This Card?

Get estimated graded values (PSA 9, PSA 10, BGS 9.5) and ROI projections.

Coming Soon

Slab Exchange

Compare graded card prices across PSA, BGS, and CGC. Track slab premium trends.

Coming Soon
Upgrade to unlock: View Plans
Markets Portfolio Search Sign In