Urza's Guilt Price

Updated 2026-09-13

Urza's Guilt from Planeshift is a Rare with a ninety-day appreciation that is among the largest in the catalog, reflecting a significant repricing earlier in that window. Urza's Guilt is a four-mana black sorcery that forces all players to discard their hands and lose life equal to the number of cards discarded, an effect with use in hand-disruption Commander strategies and group-slug builds. Planeshift was a 2001 set with a modest print run, and NM copies of Planeshift Rares are genuinely scarce after twenty-five years in circulation. The seven-day and thirty-day data are flat, consistent with the market absorbing the initial repricing and finding a new equilibrium. The ninety-day move is too large for incremental demand: a specific buying event likely drove the spike. The key question is whether organic Commander demand supports the current level. Watch for secondary market supply returning as the primary signal on price sustainability.