What is the current price of Fluttershy?

Fluttershy from Secret Lair Drop Series (Mythic, Foil) is at $38.32 near-mint market price and +0.5% on the last 30 days. Prices update daily.

Where can I buy Fluttershy?

Fluttershy is available at TCGPlayer, eBay, and most local game stores. Use the marketplace links on this card page for current listings and pricing.

How has Fluttershy moved in price recently?

Over the last 7 days, Fluttershy has moved +0.0%. Over the last 30 days, it has moved +0.5%. See the price chart on this page for the full history.

MTG

Fluttershy Price

Secret Lair Drop Series · #1538 · Mythic · Foil

$38.32 ▲ +0.0% 7d +0.5% 30d

7D HIGH

—

7D LOW

—

7D AVG

—

30D AVG

LGS TRADE-IN VALUE:

$21.08-$26.82*

Buy on TCGPlayer Buy on eBay

PRICE HISTORY: NM

MARKET NOTE: FLUTTERSHY

Updated 2026-09-04

Fluttershy is a crossover mythic from the My Little Pony Secret Lair collaboration, a category of product that has historically appreciated because supply was tightly limited to a narrow ordering window and the card has no prospect of a standard reprint in a non-My Little Pony frame. Crossover Secret Lairs occupy a distinct collector tier: they appeal to fans of both the IP and the game, which widens the buyer pool beyond typical MTG singles demand. The 90-day performance reflects consistent demand from that dual audience. This is not a card that sees top-tier competitive play, so the price is driven almost entirely by collector and cube-list interest. Supply shrinks gradually as copies get graded and stored in collections. Prospective buyers should watch for any sustained crossover IP revival that could bring new fans to the card.