MTG
Nightmare Shepherd (Extended Art) Price
$5.01
▲ +3.5%
7d
+12.6% 30d
7D HIGH
—
7D LOW
—
7D AVG
—
30D AVG
LGS TRADE-IN VALUE:
$2.76-$3.51*
Industry-typical LGS trade-in: 55-70% of NM market value in store credit. Actual rates vary by shop, card demand, and condition.
PRICE HISTORY: NM
MARKET NOTE: NIGHTMARE SHEPHERD (EXTENDED ART)
Updated September 14, 2026
Quiet bid. The card has moved +3.5% over 7 days while the trailing 30-day reads +12.6%, both pointing up without any single-day spike doing the work.
TOP IN THIS SET
SIMILAR MOVERS same rarity · ±20% price
Helm of the Host
Commander: Bloomburrow
Homunculus Horde (Borderless)
Foundations
Pongify (JP Alternate Art)
Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive
Ororo Borealis - Manamorphose
Secret Lair Drop Series
Retreat to Coralhelm (Borderless)
Secret Lair Drop Series
Exotic Orchard (Extended Art)
Commander: Marvel Super Heroes
Ashroot Animist (Borderless) (Mana Foil)
Foundations
Twilight Diviner
Promo Pack: Lorwyn Eclipsed
Sanguine Bond
Commander: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth
Memnarch
Archenemy
Emeria Shepherd
Battle for Zendikar
Eldrazi Temple (Ripple Foil)
Commander: Modern Horizons 3
Ethersworn Canonist (Galaxy Foil)
Secret Lair Drop Series
Nim Deathmantle
Double Masters 2022
Blightstep Pathway
Kaldheim
Should I Grade This Card?
Get estimated graded values (PSA 9, PSA 10, BGS 9.5) and ROI projections.
Coming SoonSlab Exchange
Compare graded card prices across PSA, BGS, and CGC. Track slab premium trends.
Coming Soon Upgrade to unlock: View Plans