Riddles in the Dark (Extended Art) Price

Updated 2026-09-11

Riddles in the Dark in Extended Art promo form is one of the standout treatments from the Magic and Hobbit Secret Lair collaboration, distributed outside the standard bundle channel as a separate promo. The card illustrates the iconic Bilbo and Gollum riddle contest, a scene with recognition well beyond the Magic player base that draws Tolkien collectors who have no competitive interest in the game. Extended art promos housed in the Unique and Miscellaneous Promos catalog represent a distribution path not tied to standard set print runs, capping supply at a lower ceiling than normal set promos. There is no reprint pathway for this exact treatment, which holds the floor above comparable functional cards. Buyers are primarily completionists pursuing every variant of the Hobbit collaboration. The price reflects both the scarcity of the treatment and the franchise crossover premium.