Crumbling Ashes Price

Updated 2026-08-06

Crumbling Ashes from Eventide is a narrow but effective hate piece against decks relying on minus-one counter synergies, occupying a unique enough rules position to maintain a collector floor beyond fringe playability. Eventide is a small set from the Shadowmoor block printed in 2008, and uncommons from small sets of that era were distributed in quantities that now look genuinely scarce relative to Commander demand. The 30-day data shows meaningful appreciation while the most recent week shows the market has paused to absorb that move. This is a pattern consistent with a demand event, perhaps a Commander build centered on counter removal or renewed interest in Shadowmoor-block mechanics, that pushed buyers into the market and is now settling. The card will not lead a portfolio, but as a niche uncommon from a low-print-run set with a specific function, its floor is more durable than the price history suggests. Watch 30-day realized comps for confirmation.